PUBLISHING · NEWS · COMMENTARYA PLACE FOR THE WRITTEN WORD
A&H Productions
A & H ProductionsBOOKS. NEWS. PERSPECTIVE.
Jones Street Columns · Opinion

When Faith and State Share an Address

By Val Atkinson

Some people describe the Vatican and Israel as the only two religious states in the world. It is an understandable impression, but an inaccurate conclusion. The confusion begins with two words: "religious state." Do we mean a country governed by religious authorities? A country with an official religion? Or a country whose national identity is inseparable from a religious tradition? Those are different arrangements. Put them into the same category, and we misunderstand both religion and government.

Vatican City presents the clearest case. The pope is both a religious leader and the sovereign of a state. Its governing structure places ultimate legislative, executive, and judicial authority in his office. Vatican sovereignty serves the independence of the Holy See and its religious mission. Here, religious leadership and state authority are joined by design.

Israel is a different case. Its 2018 nation-state Basic Law identifies Israel as the nation-state of the Jewish people. But Jewish identity cannot be reduced to religious observance. It also encompasses peoplehood, history, culture, and national belonging. Indeed, the law itself describes Jewish self-determination in cultural, religious, and historical terms. Calling Israel a Jewish state does not mean that its government operates like the Vatican. Israel's government is formed through parliamentary politics, elections, and coalition building. The prime minister does not govern by holding the highest religious office. Whatever arguments one makes about religion's influence in Israeli public life, that institutional distinction matters.

Why, then, might someone single out these two states? One plausible explanation is their powerful religious symbolism. In many people's minds, the Vatican immediately means Catholicism, while Israel immediately evokes Judaism and biblical history. Their religious associations can overshadow everything else people know about them. Another possible explanation is the way the question gets framed. Someone thinking primarily about Christianity and Judaism may overlook countries where Islam has an explicit constitutional position. Familiarity becomes a substitute for a worldwide comparison.

Saudi Arabia alone disproves the claim that only two states formally connect religion and government. Its Basic Law identifies Islam as the state's religion and the Quran and the Prophet's Sunnah as its constitution. This is considerably more than a population sharing a common faith. It is a formal foundation of governmental authority.

Nor are official religious arrangements limited to the Middle East. Denmark's constitution establishes the Evangelical Lutheran Church and provides for state support. That does not make Denmark another Vatican. It demonstrates why an established church and government by religious authorities must not be treated as interchangeable.

The phrase "religious state," without a definition, conceals more than it explains. For me, the deeper question concerns citizenship. When government identifies itself with a particular faith or people, what happens to those who do not share that identity? Can they participate equally? Can they challenge authority? Can they practice another religion — or no religion — without losing their standing as citizens?

Those questions should be asked consistently. A familiar faith should not receive a free pass, and an unfamiliar faith should not automatically provoke suspicion. Religious belief can inspire service, courage, and demands for justice. It can also be invoked to shield political power from criticism. The democratic test is whether people can hold their government accountable, including when its leaders claim a sacred purpose.

The Vatican and Israel illustrate two different relationships between identity, religion, and sovereignty. They do not exhaust the possibilities. Before we count the world's religious states, we ought to decide what we are counting. And before we praise or condemn any of them, we ought to ask how they treat the people who live under their authority.

Reader Comments