PUBLISHING · NEWS · COMMENTARYA PLACE FOR THE WRITTEN WORD
A&H Productions
A & H ProductionsBOOKS. NEWS. PERSPECTIVE.
Jones Street Columns · Opinion

Louisiana v. Callais

By Val Atkinson

There are moments in American politics when history doesn't just echo — it threatens to repeat itself. The recent ruling in Louisiana v. Callais should have every Black voter, every elected official, and frankly anyone who claims to believe in representative democracy, paying very close attention. Because if you connect the dots honestly, the path we're on doesn't just bend backward — it risks snapping all the way back to a time when Black representation in Congress was wiped clean.

Yes, wiped clean. From 1901 to 1929, there were zero Black members of the U.S. House of Representatives. Not one. That wasn't accidental. That was engineered — through voter suppression, intimidation, and, most effectively, redistricting schemes designed to dilute Black political power until it disappeared. Sound familiar?

The Court's willingness in Callais to weaken protections around majority-Black districts sends a clear signal: the legal guardrails that helped produce Black representation over the last half-century are no longer secure. And once those guardrails are gone, the political machinery that perfected exclusion once before is still very much capable of doing it again.

We've seen this movie before. At the center of that last chapter was George H. White — North Carolina's own, and the last Black congressman of his era. When White left office in 1901, he delivered what should still haunt this country. He said Black Americans were, in effect, being told to "go back to the state of servitude." And then he added something even more prophetic: that his departure was temporary — that a "phoenix-like" rise would come again. It did. But it took nearly 30 years.

Think about that. An entire generation of Black Americans lived and died without a single representative in Congress who looked like them, spoke for them, or was accountable to them. That didn't happen because Black voters disappeared. It happened because their voting strength was carved up — packed into irrelevance or cracked into invisibility. And now, here we are again, debating whether the very tools that helped reverse that injustice should still exist.

Let's be clear: this isn't about abstract legal theory. This is about power — who has it, who keeps it, and who loses it. When courts signal that states can dismantle majority-Black districts with fewer consequences, legislatures hear that loud and clear. And in states across the South — and not just the South — the temptation to redraw maps in ways that diminish Black voting strength will be more than temptation. It will be action.

North Carolina knows this game better than most. We've lived through the packing and cracking. We've watched maps get struck down and redrawn again and again, each time shaving down the influence of Black voters just a little more. So don't tell me this can't happen. Don't tell me we're past that. History says otherwise.

And if we're not vigilant, if we treat this moment like just another court decision instead of the warning shot it is, we could very well see a future where Black representation in Congress isn't just reduced — it's erased in whole regions of this country. That's not alarmism. That's precedent. George H. White warned us once before. The question now is whether we're paying attention — or whether we're comfortable sleepwalking back into a reality we already fought too hard to escape. Because once representation is gone, getting it back isn't quick, and it sure isn't easy. Just ask history.

Reader Comments