PUBLISHING · NEWS · COMMENTARYA PLACE FOR THE WRITTEN WORD
A&H Productions
A & H ProductionsBOOKS. NEWS. PERSPECTIVE.
Jones Street Columns · Opinion

De facto Martial Law

By Val Atkinson

Donald Trump told America exactly what he intended to do. He said he would be a "dictator on day one." Too many people laughed it off as campaign theater. Others treated it like hyperbole. But what we are witnessing now looks less like exaggeration and more like implementation.

What we're experiencing now is not formal martial law with tanks rolling through the streets and military checkpoints on every corner; no, we're experiencing something more dangerous in a democracy — De facto Martial Law. A De facto Martial Law brings in a condition where the institutions still exist on paper, elections still occur, courts still issue rulings, and Congress still gavels in and out of session, but power increasingly flows through one man demanding personal loyalty above constitutional duty.

That is the real significance of Project 2025. It was never merely a conservative policy wish list. It was a blueprint for centralized executive control. It envisioned replacing large portions of the professional civil service with ideological loyalists, weakening institutional independence, and concentrating authority in the presidency in ways America has historically resisted. The frightening part is not simply that such a document exists. The frightening part is how much of it is already becoming normalized.

The American system was designed with guardrails. Congress was supposed to defend its institutional authority. The judiciary was supposed to serve as an independent constitutional referee. But instead of checks and balances, what we increasingly see are parallel power centers orbiting around Trump himself. House Speaker Mike Johnson has largely transformed the House Republican Conference into an enforcement arm for Trump's political priorities. Senate Majority Leader John Thune appears to understand that survival inside today's Republican Party depends less on legislative independence and more on avoiding Trump's wrath. And Chief Justice John Roberts (along with informal group leader Samuel Alito) now presides over a Supreme Court whose decisions have steadily expanded presidential immunity and executive latitude at precisely the moment America needs stronger constitutional restraints.

None of this happens in isolation. Trump's real enforcement mechanism is not merely the presidency, it is fear: Political fear, Electoral fear, and Career-ending fear. Trump has weaponized GOP primaries into ideological tribunals. Republicans no longer fear Democratic opponents nearly as much as they fear becoming the next target of Trump-backed retaliation. Every elected Republican now understands the rules: loyalty is rewarded; dissent is punished.

Last Tuesday's primary elections reinforced this message with stunning clarity. Trump-backed candidates once again flexed enormous power over the Republican electorate. In Kentucky, Rep. Thomas Massie — one of the few Republicans willing to openly challenge Trump — was defeated by Trump-endorsed Ed Gallrein after a brutal and expensive campaign that became a national loyalty test. In Texas, Trump endorsed Attorney General Ken Paxton over longtime incumbent Senator John Cornyn, signaling once again that institutional seniority means nothing if personal loyalty to Trump is in question. Across multiple states, Trump-aligned candidates continued defeating or intimidating Republicans who had resisted his agenda.

This is how modern authoritarian systems evolve, not necessarily through some sort of dramatic coup. Oftentimes it's through gradual submission. A legislature that stops legislating independently, a judiciary that increasingly refuses to confront executive excess, a political party that becomes transformed from an ideological coalition into a personality cult are all fodder for the De facto Martial Law we find ourselves in today. Under these conditions, elections still occur, media companies still broadcast the news, but they too are compromised to satisfy the lone leader at the top.

America's founders feared concentrated power precisely because they understood human nature. They did not design a government that depended on the moral restraint of the one man at the top. They designed a system that assumed ambition, ego, revenge, and corruption would always exist. That is why they dispersed power — "checks and balances". But dispersed power only works if the people occupying institutions are willing to defend the institutions themselves.

Today, many Republicans privately know what is happening. They see it, they discuss it quietly, but public silence has become the price of political survival. Trump does not merely lead the Republican Party anymore, increasingly, he defines reality inside it. And that is the deepest warning sign of all. In true democracies, leaders serve constitutions. In authoritarian movements, constitutions serve leaders. America now stands dangerously close to finding out which model will prevail.

Reader Comments